Comma Before or After But

The comma before and after "but" plays a crucial role in clarifying the relationships between different elements within a sentence. When used correctly, it helps to delineate contrasting or opposing ideas, making the text more coherent and easier to understand.

The placement of a comma before and after the word "but" can significantly affect the meaning and structure of a sentence. Let's delve into the distinctions between these two uses:

When is comma used before but?

When a comma precedes "but," it often indicates that you are dealing with two independent clauses connected by a coordinating conjunction. This construction is known as a compound sentence.

Example sentence

She wanted to go to the concert, but she didn't have a ticket.

In this case, "She wanted to go to the concert" and "she didn't have a ticket" are both independent clauses, and the comma before "but" signifies that they are related but distinct ideas. The comma separates the clauses, allowing each to stand alone as a complete thought.

When is comma used after but?

When a comma appears after "but," it typically indicates the use of an introductory element or a parenthetical phrase. This is done to provide additional information or set the stage for the main part of the sentence.

Example sentence

But, surprisingly, the weather was perfect for the outdoor event.

In this instance, "surprisingly" is an introductory element that adds context to the main statement, "the weather was perfect for the outdoor event." The comma after "but" sets off this introductory element and helps the reader understand that it's separate from the main idea.

In summary, the comma before "but" is often used to separate two independent clauses in a compound sentence, while the comma after "but" is employed when introducing an element or phrase that provides additional information but is not essential to the sentence's structure. Understanding these differences in comma usage is essential for conveying precise meaning and maintaining proper punctuation in writing.

Practice Questions

*Put B for Before, A for After, and X for no comma needed

She wanted to visit the museum but she didn't have enough time. _______
He enjoys hiking but also enjoys biking. _______
It rained heavily but surprisingly the picnic wasn't canceled. _______
They were exhausted but they had to keep working. _______
I like both chocolate and vanilla ice cream but chose chocolate. _______
Sarah wanted to go swimming but her friends wanted to stay home. _______
Tom is smart but sometimes can be forgetful. _______
I'm tired but I have a lot of work to finish tonight. _______
The concert was fantastic but it was also very loud. _______
The dog is cute but is a bit mischievous. _______

Want to sound like a native speaker?

Engram’s AI-powered grammar checker makes your English sound like a native speaker’s, suggesting natural English expressions on top of fixing grammar, spelling, punctuation, word order, and vocabulary.

Answers:

B, the comma is placed before "but" because it separates two independent clauses.
X, no comma is needed because "but" connects two closely related ideas in a single clause.
A, the comma is placed after "but" because "surprisingly" is an introductory element.
B, the comma is placed before "but" because it separates two independent clauses.
X, no comma is needed because "but" connects two closely related ideas in a single clause.
B, the comma is placed before "but" because it separates two independent clauses.
X, no comma is needed because "but" connects two closely related ideas in a single clause.
B, the comma is placed before "but" because it separates two independent clauses.
B, the comma is placed before "but" because it separates two independent clauses.
X, no comma is needed because "but" connects two closely related ideas in a single clause.

Reference: